Monday, May 28, 2007

Composting Snot

I’ve been looking at ways to reduce the biggest component of our garbage: snot-filled Kleenex. Yes, I’m ashamed to admit that I use a major name brand of tissue that’s not even made from recycled fibers. I feel bad about this but my sweetie and I can easily go through 50 tissues day, especially with allergies this time of year.

“All the more reason you should buy recycled!,” you say. I agree, but my nose simply cannot take being wiped with the equivalent of 400-grit sandpaper over two dozen times a day. The skin and tissue (mine!) would be beyond raw.

We’ve thought about the hankie route. The concern again is with the sheer volume of mucus. There is no way a single kerchief is going to absorb that much snot. And, I’m usually not squeamish, but there is also no way that I want to store a disgusting soaked hankie in my pocket or purse. To be on the safe side, we would need at least a dozen hankies each. Where does one store that many, both clean and soiled? Do we buy a gross (a dozen dozen) to keep on hand so that we don’t have to do laundry every night? I just can’t figure out the logistics of this, especially with scarce water resources in the desert.

Maybe there’s an alternative to adding to the waste stream. In my research on what is allowable in compost, a number of sites list used paper towels and tissues. Well, we very rarely use paper towels, but we sure do use tissues. My concern here is with bacteria and other nasties.

A study published in the Journal of Infectious Diseases in October 2006 reports:

Many people carry Staphylococcus aureus, a potential disease-causing microbe, in their nose and now new research shows that large amounts of this organism and other bacteria are released into the air with every sneeze.
In a discussion on food poisoning, Health A to Z cautions:

It is estimated that 50% of healthy people have the bacteria Staphylococcus aureus in their nasal passages and throat, and on their skin and hair. Rubbing a runny nose, then touching food can introduce the bacteria into cooked food. Bacteria flourish at room temperature, and will rapidly grow into quantities capable of making people sick.
Could I safely throw our tissues in the compost pile and then confidently use that compost on food crops? I’ve searched online and had trouble finding any references at all to whether this is a legitimate concern. Yesterday, I saw that John and Louisa in the UK recommend that you do not try to compost your snot due to the possibility that pathogens will survive the composting process.


On Joseph Jenkins’ Humanure site, he instructs composters to allow composted toilet material to age for one year before applying it to your soil. If the compost temperature is maintained at the proper heat levels, the finished compost can be used on food crops.

So yes, I’m confident that in the right composting conditions, composting our snotty tissues would render the pathogens harmless. Unfortunately, our current situation does not allow us to set up an appropriate composting system and have the time to age it properly.

Will I be composting my snot anytime soon? Probably not. Will I try composting my snot in the future? You bet! I’ve already warned my sweetie that we will be doing the humanure thing at some point. (Hopefully this won’t be grounds for divorce!)

What I will do now is try every brand of recycled tissue available in the area to see if there is one that can be used at least 10-25% of the time. I will also look into a small hankie stash for those days when the mucus is not running out of my nasal passages with the stamina and determination of a marathon runner.

17 comments:

kwiltsfl said...

Whoa - TMI on the snot! Just kidding! I'm enjoying your blog!

Karen

Chile said...

Hm, new idea on the allergy problems. We run our fan early in the morning to cool the house down for the day. My sweetie suggested running the pump on the swamp cooler for a few minutes first to wet down the pads. This might help stop some of the pollen from being blown into the house, reduce the sneezing, and consequently lower tissue use. It's worth a try!

Karen, I'm glad you like the blog.

Marla said...

I commend you on your search for a greener way to solve your snotty problems. I am married to an allergy sufferer who honks into hankies, going through about 3 a day. On bad days this can lead to rawness. I think it would be great if you could stop the problem at the source, so to speak, by reducing your nasal secretions somehow....but failing that, your future composting plan sounds ideal. Loving your blog!

Alina said...

Lolol... Some people say that eating your buggers strengthens your immune system (check this out - http://www.damninteresting.com/?p=271)

I dunno... Sometimes I suspect that I don't really believe in germs, because I am not a germophobe at all... I couldn't care less about germs. I would compost it and not think twice about it :p

And I think tissues might be worse than hankies when it comes to leaving your nose in raw flesh, at least when I have a cold my nose looks like an opened one after one day with paper tissues, no matter how good they are.

Your blog is looking nice! Keep it up :)

Chile said...

Thanks, Alina, for coming out of your environmental closet to check out my blog! Regarding the immunity article, note the Doc recommends eating dried boogers. Unfortunately, my nose produces copious amounts of mucus rarely allowing much drying to happen. Thanks for the suggestion, though! :)

I looked for nice soft organic cotton hankies yesterday without success. That may require a mail-order. The quest continues for a solution to the snotty problem!

Crunchy Chicken said...

If you can find a recycled tissue that doesn't remove the first 5 layers of your epithelial cells, let me know. I'm working through a box of Seventh Generation and, while I can tolerate their TP, this stuff makes me dream about Kleenex with Lotion.

Chile said...

Well, Crunchy Chicken, I just happen to have 4 different boxes of recycled tissues sitting next to me waiting to be tested during Low Impact Week. Also 4 brands of toilet paper.... Watch my blog for a report after they've been thoroughly tested!

Vanessa said...

It all depends on the snot consistency if you ask me... big globs of phlegm = Kleenex or recycled TP; watery runniness = cotton hanky. Everyone's talking about this Neti Pot thing; maybe that's worth a try?

P.S. What on eath is a swamp cooler? And how do I get one? :)

Chile said...

Howdy Vanessa! It may be TMI, but we're talkin' mucous with some body to it. *sigh* I do have a neti pot but it doesn't relieve allergies. It's great when I have an actual sinus infection but I rarely get those since giving up all dairy products.

A "swamp cooler" is also called an evaporative cooler as that better describes how it works. It's a big box lined with absorbent pads that are kept wet with trickling water. A fan pulls in outside air and blows air through the pads and into the air ducts of the house. As the air passes through the wet pads, it's cooled significantly. The catch is this system only works in low humidity.

We also apply evaporative cooling principles when walking and biking outside this time of year. I drench my hair and sometimes my shirt before a run, but in the afternoon, it's so hot that my shirt is bone dry in less than half an hour!

-Sun-roasted Chile ;-)

vwsista said...

Hi. Just found a link to your blog from Crunchy Chicken and this post caught my attention. I am a long time allergy sufferer, too. Ugh... I use hankies that I've purchased second hand at estate sales or garage sales. They are vintage and very soft and pretty. I only buy them if they are not faded or stained otherwise I'd be grossed out but they seem to do the trick... I also use bandanas or soft tank tops or T-shirts if I'm around the house.

I'm digging your blog so far. The soup sounded scrumptious!

Chile said...

Thanks for the tip, vwsista! I'll keep an eye out at the estate sales. Glad you enjoyed the soup recipe.

Joann said...

I am having the same dilemma. I use the old hankies, but somehow there are always tissues......we just built a doggie doo composter and was wondering if I could throw the tissues in with that? any ideas???

Chile said...

Joann - I think it would work to throw them in the doggie composter. Just make sure you make it big enough for all the dog droppings and used tissues.

Sharlene T. said...

OK, maybe I'm dense, here, but why not simply burn them daily in a small container and then add the ash to your compost pile? Snot sterilized and compost enriched.

Chile said...

Great idea, Sharlene. Thanks!

Shana said...

I have crazy, crazy, crazy allergies. When tested as a kid, I came up positive for 36 of the 40 allergens they scratched me with. I spent quite awhile fruitlessly searching for recycled paper tissues that were actually soft enough not to bother me AT ALL, but finally found some.

I order Green Forest tissues by the case from my local natural foods store, who carries about two boxes at a time, which just doesn't cut it if you want to drive less. I also use hankies, but as you've noted, sometimes it's not practical, so I go through about a case of tissues a year. However, these ones really are soft enough for use when wiping and blowing what feels like a thousand times a day. (I'm a sensitive-skinned priss, and now prefer the GF over the super-thick virgin-fiber ones, because the comfort is equivalent, to me. They feel different, but not worse or harsher or rougher, if that makes any sense, and I hated the piles and piles of virgin tissues.)

Anyway. At my hippie store, they're $2 for a box of 200, I think. Box says 100% recycled paper, minimum 90% post-consumer, whitened without chlorine. Before I found someone at said hippie store who would order them, I ordered yearly from Amazon, which is certainly less than ideal, but an option if you don't have someone local who carries 'em.

Tissue evangelizing seems crazy, but I suppose that the very few eco-minded folks who realize that "just use a hanky, treekiller!" isn't always practical have to suck that up. :) Good luck!

Chile said...

Shana - thanks for sharing. I think I've used the GF paper towels (for dog puke emergencies) but I can't recall for sure if I tried the tissues. I thought I did and found them lacking but I'll pick up a new box on your recommendation and give it another blow. Spring allergy season is coming up and I'll be using a lot!