Sunday, October 26, 2008

I Must Withdraw My Endorsement

It is with regret that I withdraw my recommendation for the Vortex hand-cranked blender. When I first got it, I thought it had great potential even though I had reservations about the Lexan material. There are potential health concerns with Lexan and contact with hot materials can degrade the plastic, causing premature wear and cracking. But, I vowed to only blend foods and liquids that were room temperature or cooler, and not let them sit for any length of time in the container.

As I began using it, though, I noticed some problems. The first one was that it did not blend and puree foods nearly as well as the Krups electric blender that I, unfortunately, impetuously sold on craigslist as soon as I'd purchased the Vortex. Oh well, I thought, I'm not a perfectionist. I can live with soup that is not perfectly smooth and silky.

The second problem is a design flaw that seems to be common for the manufacturer (GSI). The bottom of the blender twists into the base in a clockwise direction. The body of the blender screws into the bottom in a clockwise direction. When the blending is complete and it's time to remove the blender from the base, this has to be done carefully while holding the bottom. If I try to remove it by twisting the blender body (rotating it counterclockwise to remove it from the base), it simultaneously unscrews the body from the bottom. Not surprisingly, this results in a big mess. A better design would have been to have the bottom twist into the base in the opposite direction as the body screws onto the base.

This was also a problem with GSI's manual coffee grinder, which led me to return it to the store. I called the company and they were unsympathetic. Customer satisfaction did not seem to be high on their list of priorities. The store was not thrilled with the return either.

The third problem is the thin silicone gasket between the bottom and body of the blender. The hard silicone just doesn't form as good a seal as the traditional rubber gaskets usually used in blenders. I have had serious problem with leaking. It's very annoying to pour all of the ingredients in the blender and then notice liquid leaking out the bottom. This became such a persistant problem that I'd put a cup of water in it before using it just to test for leaks and make sure the gasket was seated well.

I did that this evening. It seemed fine. By the time I'd put all the ingredients in it for the fake (vegan) cheesy sauce I was making though, there was a drizzle of liquid coming out of the blender bottom. I hollered at my sweetie to get the food processor out and I dumped the contents in it.

"That's it!" I fumed, "I am not keeping this POS!" It did not help matters that the food processor leaked out half the liquid either. Whether it was overly full or one of the cracks in its Lexan body has finally given way is a matter for another day.

I now have to decide whether to replace the Vortex with a new electric blender or try to do everything in the food processor, which, as I mentioned, is wearing out. I prefer to use a blender for those things with a high liquid content, such as flax seed egg substitute, sauces, and pureed soups, and the food processor for blending thicker foods such as cooked pumpkin and occasionally for shredding larger quantities of food such as cabbage for sauerkraut.

Can I do these by hand? Mostly, but not as well and not very fast. The chopping takes far longer but can be done. Cooked pumpkin can be mashed with a potato masher, but may not be as smooth. Mixing the flax seed egg substitute, though, really works best at sustained high blender speed for several minutes. And forget making whole wheat berry pancakes by hand. (Actually, I haven't made these since I sold the electric blender. The berries would scratch the heck out of the Vortex and I don't think it would grind them up anyway, even if I could sustain a high speed for a full five minutes.)

So, right now I'm not quite sure what I'll do to blend foods. I am sure, though, that I will not be keeping the Vortex blender. I'll put it on craigslist. Perhaps some fraternity at the university will buy it so they can have fun making blended drinks at their parties. I'm very disappointed at I'd hoped this tool would help me keep moving towards a lower energy lifestyle.

23 comments:

belinda said...

Hi Chile.

How annoying, all of those issues are important when it comes to the usefulness of a blender.

Thanks for outlining your issues..will help me know what to keep in mind when I need to make a decision on this issue myself.

Kind Regards
Belinda

badhuman said...

You could try and find a used food processor or blender on craigslist or a thrift store. I know they aren't as eco friendly as a hand cranked model but buying used would be better then buying new. My mom actually got me a simple hand cranked "food processor" from tupperware. It has bowl and blade like a regular food processor and then you crank it around yourself. It works well for chopping, not as well for getting stuff really smooth but that could be laziness on my part. I'm not sure of the materials but overall I'm really happy with it (and it doesn't leak)

Chile said...

Belinda - I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but I hate badly designed "green" products even more.

BadHuman - if you're talking about something like the Rocket Chef, I've already tried one and been disappointed. If I decide to get a blender, I will probably just hit up the yard sales. There was one Saturday that I should've bought!

plantainpatch said...

Hey Chile,

I also have this blender. I don't use it often because it is a bit of a pain. I relied on my food processor and it died earlier this summer. I have been doing everything by hand. I don't make cheese sauces though. I am wondering how I will do pesto next garden season though. Mortar and pestle?

I also use flaxseed as an substitute but heat it in a small saucepan instead of blending. It comes out great. Like egg white.

Thanks for the review! I will continue not to use it for anything but smoothies.

AMorris said...

Ok, your sweetie is mechanically inclined and you love yard sales. Why not find a nice blender at a yard sale and hack into it? I'm sure that with all of the bike parts lying around, some sort of bicycle-driven blender can be made.
http://blog.makezine.com/archive/2006/06/bicycle_blenders.html

Chile said...

PlantainPatch - I saw the heating flax directions when I wrote up the egg substitutes post. I'll have to try that out.

AMorris - Thanks for the suggestion. I've passed the link on to him. Maybe I'll get a nice bike blender out of it!

Anonymous said...

For food processing (at least shredding or slicing carrots, etc.) I would recommend a Mouli Julienne. I have my mother's from the 1950s and it works like a charm. I've seen them for sale on ebay. I have heard that the current plastic based models do not work as well as the pre 1980's models. The website for the company that still makes them is:
http://www.moulinex.co.uk/pages/food_cljulie.html

For blending, I have not found anything better than my glass container electric blender. However, for sauces I sometimes use a single handle egg beater. You work it by pressing up and down on the handle. Mine was made by Ecco in the 1960's or 1970's.

--Ave

Chile said...

Ave - I use a whisk for a lot of sauces now. I'll check out that other gadget.

Rosa said...

if you get a bike blender, I want to see it in action! I really want one that uses mechanical power and all the bike geeks I know who've made them do the bike-electricity-electric blender thing, which seems really wasteful.

Melinda said...

Oh boy. Blenders are difficult. Sounds like a horrible design flaw! Can your sweetie adapt a motorized blender from the thrift store into a hand-cranked one? Maybe using parts from each of the blenders? Sounds like a fun project! ; )

Melinda said...

LOL - just read the comments - looks like amorris had a similar idea!

Chile said...

He says he'll make me a bike blender (direct action, not generator to electric blender thing) that we can mount on the same exercise bike we use for grinding wheat. It will probably mount right on that flat part above the front wheel.

Verde said...

Bummer. I was set for one myself but now I don't think so.

I'm not even that happy with electric blenders anymore. The one my grandmother got for opening a bank account in the 70's finally bit it with it's last frozen drink.

Robj98168 said...

I am sorry the vortex didn't wwork out for you- That is really dissapointing. I don't think I will ever find a hand grinder that works well. My mom had one that ground well but took forever to grind enough beans for one pot of coffee.

Anonymous said...

I use the avocado green Oster blender my parents bought in the 1970s, it has the original glass pitcher and I've only replaced the blades and gasket once. It still works great, what a shame that things are no longer built to last.

At a city bike event they had a make-your-own-smoothie station. The bike blender they used worked amazingly well. I can't remember the manufacturer but I'm sure you can find them online or make your own. In Moab this year we had a solar powered blender an engineer rigged up, not sure how he did it though.

good luck,
diana

Rosa said...

diana, was it the Extracycle blender?

Chile said...

Bike Blender makes a high quality product. Each blender base is individually machined. However, you have to pay for such quality and we just can't see investing that amount in something for home use. Now, if I intended to spend my summers biking around the city selling smoothies, that'd be different...

Domestic Accident said...

Chile, can you live with yourself if you contribute to the drunken behavior of sorority girls? For what other purpose would a frat boy be in the kitchen?

Chile said...

Domestic Accident, are you offering to buy this from me to save the sorority girls? ;-)

jte said...

I've got a Vortex as well and my experience has been mixed. I wasn't a fan of the fact that the container part is Lexan, but I only use it for colder foods (really almost only for smoothies) so I didn't fret about that too much. And for those smoothies, it always worked just fine for me as long as I didn't dump too much frozen fruit into the bottom at one time. I'd make sure to layer my ingredients starting with liquids first, so that I could get up to speed a little with my cranking before the hard stuff began getting involved in the spinning blades.

But the sucker died on me after a while when the metal clamp that held it to the countertop snapped. Without that, it's basically useless.

I had high hopes. I know Tamara Dean (author of The Human-Powered Home, through whose website I came across the Chile Chews review of the Vortex) advocates for bike-powered blenders instead of the Vortex. I'm still not sold. Though I won't buy another Vortex, I still believe that for my uses, a hand-crank blender is a better design than a bike blender. My kitchen isn't big enough for a bike, and I don't want to have to do my blending out in the barn or bring my bike inside just to make a smoothie and then take it back outside again. Maybe I'll be able to cannibalize the Vortex's parts to create a new and better hand-crank blender.

Chile said...

JTE, thanks for sharing your experience with the Vortex. I've read other reviews online that mention that particular part snapping off, so it must be another design flaw.

I do agree with your reservations about the bike blender. We'll probably go ahead with it, though, since we already have an exercise bike set-up for grain grinding. During hotter weather, we bring it inside but now that it's cooling off, we can just leave it on the patio outside and use it anytime.

While it's not the most convenient to have to carry food out of the kitchen to prepare it, I've gotten accustomed to that with using two solar ovens.

Good luck with making a new hand-cranked blender set-up!

Rob said...

Thanks for sharing. I wish I found this post before I bought a vortex. The bottom of the pitcher cracked on mine and now I'm stuck with a $80 paperweight. I even got a replacement o-ring from GSI but it didn't help the leaking. I'm definitely going to get a glass blender as a replacement.

Callum said...

I stumbled upon your article, thanks for sharing, you've told me the GSI hand crank blender is not the one for me. I salute your good citizenry in sharing this information. :-)

I also came across the folks at TreeHugger.com talking about the same device and linking to another one. That product no longer exists as far as I can tell, but it got me onto Lehman's. They sell a hand crank food processor, althought it's a slightly different proposition at $650! They make or sell some really interesting electricity free stuff, although it's old fashioned quality apparently, which means old school prices.